Bob Kirby and Tom Kenney recently achieved a major victory before the Massachusetts Appeals Court in a case concerning the ownership of a decedent’s email content. Our clients were the duly appointed administrators of the estate of their late brother and had requested access to his Yahoo! email account in connection with their efforts to marshal estate assets. When Yahoo! refused, Pierce & Mandell filed suit in Norfolk Probate Court seeking an Order requiring Yahoo! to provide access to the email account. The Probate Court dismissed the lawsuit, finding that Yahoo!’s on-line terms and conditions required that suit be brought in California, and that a prior consent judgment between the parties barred further litigation under principles of res judicata.
However, after extensive briefing and argument before a three-judge panel, the Massachusetts Appeals Court disagreed and vacated the Probate Court’s dismissal of the complaint. The Appeals Court held that the forum selection clause in Yahoo!’s on-line terms and conditions was not enforceable absent evidence that the decedent received proper notice of the terms and provided Yahoo! with meaningful assent.
The Appeals Court also ruled that the prior consent judgment was the result of the parties’ agreement to settle one issue in dispute and leave the larger issue – ownership of the email content – for later resolution. As a result, the Appeals Court ruled that it would contradict the intent of the parties’ agreement, as well as frustrate the purposes of settlements generally, to permit a consent judgment on one issue to bar the parties from seeking judicial determination of other disputes.
The Appeals Court remanded the case to the Probate Court for a determination of whether the email content is an asset of the estate.
Click here to read the May 16, 2013 Lawyers Weekly Article concerning the Appeals Court ruling.
Probate Law and Litigation
Grab Probate Law and Litigation RSS Feed
Pierce & Mandell Lawyers Score Appeals Court Victory Over Yahoo!
Wednesday, May 29, 2013
1
Recent Posts
- Pierce & Mandell Lawyers Secure Landmark Supreme Judicial Court Victory
- Pierce & Mandell Probate Lawyers Secure Appeals Court Victory In Case Involving Interpretation Of A Will
- Robert Kirby Argues Privacy Case in the SJC
- Supreme Judicial Court Takes Appeal in Case Involving the Stored Communications Act
- Pierce & Mandell Probate Litigators Granted Summary Judgment in Will Contest Lawsuit
- Recent Appeals Court Decision Highlights the Importance of Effective Estate Planning to Avoid Post-Mortem Litigation
- Estate Planning: The Lay of the Land - Boston
- Pierce & Mandell Lawyers Score Appeals Court Victory Over Yahoo!
- “Undue Influence” and Shifting Burdens of Proof in Massachusetts Probate Court
- Massachusetts Adopts Uniform Trust Code
Archive
Tags
- Bob Kirby, Boston (1)
- Boston attorneys (1)
- challenging a will, Boston (1)
- comprehensive estate plan (1)
- estate plan (1)
- estate planning FAQs, Boston (1)
- estate planning, Boston (1)
- fiduciary and probate litigation (1)
- fiduciary law, Boston (1)
- health care proxy, Boston (1)
- irrevocable life insurance trust, Boston (1)
- living family trust, Boston (1)
- Massachusetts uniform trust code (1)
- Michael C. Fee (1)
- MUTC (1)
- Pierce & Mandell, P.C. (3)
- Pierce and Mandell P.C. (3)
- power of attorney, Boston (1)
- Privacy Case (1)
- Proabate Law and Litigation (1)
- probate and fiduciary administration (1)
- probate and fiduciary law, Boston (2)
- probate attorney (1)
- probate attorneys, Boston (1)
- probate law, Boston (2)
- probate laws, Boston (2)
- proceedings in probate court, Boston (1)
- provisions (1)
- rights of trust beneficiaries (1)
- Robert L. Kirby, Jr (1)
- Scott M. Zanolli (1)
- Scott M. Zanolli, Esq. (1)
- Scott Zanolli (1)
- support trust, Boston (1)
- Supreme Judicial Court (1)
- The Massachusetts Uniform Trust Code (1)
- Tom Kenney, Boston (1)
- trust matters (1)
- trusts (1)
- undue influence, Boston (1)
- uniform trust code (1)
- will contests, Boston (1)
- will or trust, Boston (1)
- will preparation, Boston (1)
Comments